Leadership and Overcoming Coordination Failure with Asymmetric Costs

• Authors: Jordi Brandts.
• BSE Working Paper: 112283 | September 15
• Keywords: experiments , Coordination , Organizational change , Heterogeneous agents , Leadership
• JEL codes: C70, C90, D63, D64
• experiments
• Coordination
• Organizational change
• Heterogeneous agents
• Leadership

We study how the heterogeneity of agents affects the extent to which changes in financial incentives can pull a group out of a situation of coordination failure. We focus on the connections between cost asymmetries and leadership. Experimental subjects interact in groups of four in a series of weak-link games. The treatment variable is the distribution of high and low effort cost across subjects. We present data for one, two and three low-cost subjects as well as control sessions with symmetric costs. The overall pattern of coordination improvement is common across treatments. Early coordination improvements depend on the distribution of high and low effort costs across subjects, but these differences disappear with time. We find that initial leadership in overcoming coordination failure is not driven by low-cost subjects but by subjects with the most frequent cost. This conformity effect can be due to a kind of group identity or to the cognitive simplicity of acting with identical others.