Secondary Victimization of Women Reporting Violence

  • Authors: Caterina Muratori
  • BSE Working Paper: 1616 | November 2026
  • Keywords: gender norms, Intimate partner violence, crime reporting, belief updating, secondary victimization
  • JEL codes: D83, J12, J16, K42, L82, Z13
Download PDF Download pdf Icon

Abstract

Secondary victimization, the disbelief, trivialization, and stigmatization that victims encounter upon reporting violence, shapes the incentives of both victims and perpetrators, yet its role in violence dynamics has never been formally modeled or causally identified. I develop an economic model in which a publicly observed episode of secondary victimization triggers Bayesian updating of beliefs about victim recognition, simultaneously raising the expected cost of reporting for victims and lowering the expected cost of violence for perpetrators. I test the model’s predictions exploiting the 2022 Depp v. Heard defamation trial as a source of quasi- random variation in exposure to secondary victimization. Using daily incident-level data from the National Incident-Based Reporting System and a Regression Discontinuity Difference-in- Differences design, I find that in the week following the verdict, reported intimate partner violence falls by 12.6 percent. In contrast, incidents involving major injuries rise by 34.2 percent, though imprecisely estimated. Both responses are mainly driven by states with less egalitarian gender norms and concentrated at the verdict, rather than during the proceedings, underscoring the central role of social norms and institutions in shaping the dynamics of intimate partner violence.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Want to receive the latest news and updates from the BSE? Share your details below.
Founding Institutions
Distinctions
Logo BSE
© Barcelona Graduate School of
Economics. All rights reserved.
FacebookInstagramLinkedinXYoutube